Vitamin C powder for hull cleaning? | General Discussion | Forum

Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
Forum Login
Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
Vitamin C powder for hull cleaning?
Avatar
John Tetlow
204 Posts
(Offline)
1
16th August 2020 - 5:10 pm
Print

At the Twister meeting in February I scribbled a few notes during the afternoon discussion session.

One reads "Vitamin C powder to remove brown stains from hull" .

Can this be true or did I have too much beer with my lunch?

If it is true, is it better than oxalic acid and how do you apply it?

And where can you buy it?

Avatar
Peter Mulville
210 Posts
(Offline)
2
17th August 2020 - 11:36 am
Print

Hi John

You can buy it in bulk from the web. I found this link: https://www.tradeingredients.c.....cid-powder

Having looked it up I note that in the presence of oxygen it will decompose; one of the decomposition products is oxalic acid. 

You'd apply it as a concentrated solution in warm water. Probably be good to add a splash of washing up liquid. If you have waxed the hull you'd need to wash that off first.

Trouble is that most suppliers will supply a pharmaceutical grade. This adds cost to the basic product.

I'm pretty sure it will work. I know it will remove rust stains - but so will phosphoric acid. That's cheap on the web. 

I use Star Brite Hull Cleaner. It's very very good at removing the yellow brown stain that appears. Tip: it will discolour any antifouling - so if the boat is out of the water clean topsides first. Just wipe it on. Wait, then rinse off. Use gloves. It's acid. It's expensive but one bottle last several years.

I've looked up the composition of the Star Brite product by looking at the Material Safety Data Sheet. It's basically a 5 to 10% solution of oxalic acid with a surfacant. [i.e. a detergent. This is to 'wet out' the solution] plus a few other secret safe compounds present in very low quantities that they don't need to declare.

Peter

Avatar
John MacMullen and Ann Musgrave
154 Posts
(Offline)
3
17th August 2020 - 5:41 pm
Print

So what's wrong with Oxalic acid? A tub of crystals at around £11 generally lasts us for 4 seasons and we clean quite a lot.

Avatar
Allan Beswick
39 Posts
(Offline)
4
17th August 2020 - 8:18 pm
Print

I used Oxalic Acid to take water stains out of a wooden floor, worked well but you have no control over the degree of lighting 

Avatar
John Tetlow
204 Posts
(Offline)
5
18th August 2020 - 2:34 pm
Print

John MacMullen said
So what's wrong with Oxalic acid? A tub of crystals at around £11 generally lasts us for 4 seasons and we clean quite a lot.  

Nothing wrong with oxalic acid.

I have used at least once a year during the 23 years I have owned "Tammie Norie"; more frequently since I began keeping her on the River Vilaine, where brown staining is a problem. 

But someone mentioned using Vitamin C at the February meeting and I would like to know if there any advantages in doing so.

For example, would it be more effective at low temperatures, and might it be less damaging to the environment than oxalic acid? The authorities in the part of Brittany where "Tammie Norie" is kept are beginning to clamp down hard on activities that they think might cause environmental damage.

Avatar
John MacMullen and Ann Musgrave
154 Posts
(Offline)
6
19th August 2020 - 10:52 am
Print

We don't remember vitamin C (Ascorbic acid) being mentioned. I guess you could always try it. At best it will work AND help the fishes avoid colds and flu this winter. Win win!

Avatar
John Tetlow
204 Posts
(Offline)
7
19th August 2020 - 11:20 pm
Print

Hardly the sort of thing I would make up is it?

But maybe it is not so daft as it seems. Apparently there are cleaning products for swimming pools that are based on ascorbic acid.

Always useful to keep an open mind to new ideas.

Forum Timezone: Europe/London
Show Stats
Administrators: Peter Mulville, Alex Hooley
Top Posters:
Stephen Moorey: 268
John Tetlow: 204
John MacMullen and Ann Musgrave: 154
David Hopkins: 151
Justin Butler: 149
Crispin Bonham Carter: 87
Marcelo Affonso: 45
Philip Collcutt: 42
Mathew Small: 41
Allan Beswick: 39
Newest Members:
Alfie Kane
Tymon Kiepe
Robert McDermott
Stephen
Mihaly Ferenc Varga
Peter Westwood
Craig Dalgliesh
Mike Cassidy
Edward
Shaun Norris
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 4
Topics: 311
Posts: 2048

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 14
Members: 254
Moderators: 0
Admins: 2

Most Users Ever Online
38
Currently Online
Justin Butler
Guest(s)
2
Currently Browsing this Page

1 Guest(s)